Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Suffolk County, NY & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Suffolk County, NY

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
GEICO A++ 16%
Allstate A+ 14.09%
State Farm A 13.09%
Nationwide A+ 9%
Liberty Mutual A 8.17%

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Suffolk County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Garland D Thompson 91 Main Street
6412
(860) 526-9578
Arnold Allen Simpson 115 Old Kings Hwy N
06820-3611
203-662-1027
Donald Kennedy 333 Jackson Ave
11791
(516) 921-8484
Insurancewide Company Llc 435 MAIN ST
6468
203-268-7224
Eg Insurance Agency Inc. 200 Connecticut Ave Ste 5
6854
(203) 852-9454
Triumph Insurance Agency Llc 6800 Jericho Tpke Ste 103W
11791
Lisa Noelle Vich 81 NEW STREET
11743
631-427-4580
Thomas L Dreps 35 Audrey Ave
11771
Howard R Moccabee 59 CRABTREE LANE
6460
203-877-0630
Morgan & Associates Inc. 821 CENTER ST
6492
(203) 265-6763

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Suffolk County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Venita Salter 174 West Main Street
11730
(631)206-6795
Gregory Andersen 352 W Old Country Rd
11801
(516) 937-0700
Springer Ins Inc 725 Rxr Plaza 725 Rxr Plaza
11556
Steve Keys 70 Essex Road
6498
Cynthia Mc Ghee 218 Main St
11733
631-675-9550
Eric Zingmark 4907A Merrick Rd
11762
(516) 797-8400
Michael Schaeffer 35 Corporate Dr.
6611
1-203-268-8844
Julian Tu 24 CHERRY ST
6770
203-729-5261
David Cotter 329 E. Main Street
11787-2821
631-724-0002
Ed Scislow Jr 195 Broadway
11701
(631) 691-7474

Top GEICO Home Insurance Agents in Suffolk County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Hugh Hamilton 303 BERNICE DR
11705
516-363-5200
Email:hhamilton@geico.com
Tony Kolgaklis 47 Barnes Industrial Rd S
6492

Email:geicocharleston@geico.com
Tim Calcagno 87 Glenbrook Rd
6902
(203) 295-3988
Email:tcalcagno@geico.com

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Suffolk County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Justin Breen Lutcf 399 SACKETT POINT RD
6473
203-404-1140
Justin Brady 193 STATE ST
6473
203-288-8429
Michael J Beck Lutcf 711 Broad Street Extension
6385
(860) 446-2886
Lisa Cervin 35 AUDREY AVE
11771
516-922-6500
Jeremy Ober 6 WAY RD
6455
860-349-7071
Elisa Vieira 154 Terry Rd
11787
(631) 493-0700
Eric Silver 232 Boston Post Rd
6460
(203) 876-0085
Mark Teece Lutcf 1954 Post Rd
06824-5720
(203) 256-8029
Everett C. Johnson 104 East Ave
6851
(203) 855-8444
Jeremy J Miller Lutcf 46 PLAINS RD UNIT 31
6426
860-767-0084

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Suffolk County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Lisa Caughey 35 AUDREY AVENUE
www.lisacaughey.com 11771
516-933-8080
Justin Brown 31 BROADWAY
6473
203-234-2400
Julie Abarzua 1730 E MAIN ST
www.insuremejulie.com 6705
203-753-9530
Bob Beron 1120 Montauk Hwy Ste C
www.bobberon.com 11950-2933
631-399-9333
Jeremy Hooter 30 MAIN ST
www.jeremyhooter.com 6409
860-767-9190
Gale Fisher 3151 Main St
www.galefisher.com 6614
(203) 375-5847
Brad Warrick 102 Carleton Ave Ste 3
11752-2237
631-581-4600
Kristie Powell 711 UNION AVE
www.kristiepowell.com 11931
631-722-3500
Hilly Griffin 5 COLONY ST STE 303
6451
203-235-1025
Terry Coffman 1650 Sycamore Ave Ste 7
www.terrycoffman.com 11716

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Suffolk County, NY

Liberty MutualState FarmNationwide
Median Home Value ($) 391,460371,460351,460
Construction year 194319831994
Home Coverage ($) $300000-$350000$350000-$400000$250000-$300000
Total Premium ($) $2762$3525$2997

Suffolk County, NY Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Nationwide upto 11%
Allstate upto 24%
GEICO upto 18%
Liberty Mutual upto 17%